Allie Beth Stuckey Critiques Candace Owens Amid Controversial Claims

A significant rift has emerged within conservative circles as Christian influencer Allie Beth Stuckey publicly criticized Candace Owens over her controversial theories regarding the death of Charlie Kirk, the founder of Turning Point USA (TPUSA). Stuckey’s remarks came during a recent episode of her online show, “Relatable,” where she voiced her distress over Owens’ unfounded accusations about Kirk’s assassination.

Stuckey, who has been described by the Wall Street Journal as a potential successor to Kirk, expressed her feelings on social media after Owens suggested that those close to Kirk might have betrayed him. “I wasn’t going to respond to Candace publicly, but I was genuinely hurt by her accusation that I don’t care about who killed Charlie,” Stuckey stated. She emphasized her commitment to seeking truth within the Christian community and denounced the notion that merely asking questions could excuse slander.

Owens’ recent comments have particularly targeted Erika Kirk, Charlie’s widow, albeit without direct accusations. Stuckey pointed out the implications of Owens’ claims, stating, “When you say ‘everyone around Charlie betrayed him’…people are drawing the conclusion that the widow is in on it.” This allegation has sparked outrage and concern among Kirk’s supporters.

Stuckey’s condemnation has resonated with other conservatives. David Limbaugh, brother of the late conservative figure Rush Limbaugh, praised Stuckey’s courage on social media, stating, “Kudos and respect to Allie Beth Stuckey for her courage and telling the truth in love.” Political commentator Erielle Azerrad also commended Stuckey, implying that Owens was avoiding moral responsibility in her claims.

In a response to the backlash, Owens defended her position, stating, “I am pointing out glaring inconsistencies and outright lies that we have been told regarding Charlie’s assassination.” She labeled Stuckey a “committed Zionist” and accused her of using emotionally manipulative tactics to silence dissenting views. Owens has dismissed the findings of the FBI concerning Kirk’s death as “ridiculous,” further inflaming tensions within the community.

Charlie Kirk was fatally shot on September 10, 2025, during an event at Utah Valley University. The alleged shooter, Tyler Robinson, a 22-year-old left-wing college dropout, has since been charged with his assassination. Kirk’s death has led to a wave of conspiracy theories, particularly amplified by Owens, who has drawn scrutiny for her approach.

In the wake of his passing, Erika Kirk has stepped into a leadership role as CEO of TPUSA, vowing to continue her husband’s legacy. During a ceremony at State Farm Stadium, where over 60,000 attendees gathered to honor Charlie Kirk, former President Donald Trump provided a poignant eulogy, acknowledging the profound loss felt by many. “We know the weight of this monumental loss is almost unbearable,” Trump stated, offering comfort to Erika during a time of immense grief.

As this public dispute unfolds, it highlights the fractures within conservative circles regarding the appropriate discourse surrounding tragedy and loss. Stuckey’s candid remarks serve as a reminder of the complexities involved in navigating grief and the pursuit of truth amidst sensational claims.