Tesco Plans Potential Appeal After Council Rejection in Stonehaven

Plans for a new Tesco store in Stonehaven may soon face an appeal after local council members voted against the proposal last month. The decision raised concerns that the supermarket would divert trade from the town centre, despite assurances from Tesco executives that the store could create approximately 100 new jobs and be operational by Christmas 2024.

The Kincardine and Mearns area committee had initially expressed support for the project, while council planners recommended refusal. The infrastructure services committee ultimately rejected the plans, despite unanimous backing from local councillors. The decision has prompted developers to consider their options, with a spokesperson for Ashfield Land stating they are “considering all options regarding the Stonehaven Gateway site.”

Local sentiment towards the supermarket remains mixed. Community leaders and residents have expressed their desire for improved retail options in Stonehaven. David Lawman, chairman of the Stonehaven Community Council, remarked that the proposal would likely “receive similar support” if it were to go to appeal. He emphasized the need for Stonehaven to match the retail offerings of other towns in Aberdeenshire.

Community Perspectives on the Appeal

Support for the proposal is not limited to community leaders. Dawn Black, a local councillor representing the Scottish National Party (SNP), has been vocal in her support for the appeal. Black highlighted the unique geographic circumstances of Stonehaven, arguing that a new Tesco would not directly compete with existing businesses in the town centre.

She pointed out that many locals currently travel between 7 and 20 miles to find suitable supermarkets, which results in an estimated annual loss of £70 million from the local economy. “The majority of locals do their main grocery shopping outside of Stonehaven,” Black stated. She believes these factors should be taken into account when considering the appeal.

Black further urged that the “nature of the offering” in Stonehaven should be examined, suggesting that it is distinct from what a large supermarket would provide. “These are all material considerations I put forward for granting the application, and I would hope they would stand up to scrutiny by a reporter,” she added.

As the situation develops, residents await further news regarding the possibility of an appeal. The outcome will not only impact the retail landscape in Stonehaven but also influence local employment opportunities and economic growth. The community’s response remains a critical factor as discussions continue around the potential for a new Tesco store in the area.