Ranking Wrexham’s Top 10 Players in Club History

Wrexham AFC, a historic football club in Wales, has surged into the spotlight since its acquisition by Hollywood stars Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney in February 2021. The club’s visibility has expanded globally, notably through the documentary series “Welcome to Wrexham.” As of the 2025/2026 season, Wrexham competes in the Championship, marking their first appearance in the second tier of English football since the 1981/1982 season. This ascent, characterized by three consecutive promotions, has sparked discussions about the club’s legacy and its greatest players.

As Wrexham prepares for a potential move to the Premier League, fans reflect on the ten players who have left an indelible mark on the club’s history. Here’s a look at these football legends:

10. Karl Connolly

Brought into the first team by manager Brian Flynn, Karl Connolly found his footing at Wrexham after transitioning from a left-wing position to a primary striker. His impactful performances earned him a spot on the PFA Team of the Year in the 1995/1996 season, showcasing his role in the club’s successful cup run that followed.

9. Gary Bennett

With an impressive record of 114 goals in just 177 appearances, Gary Bennett is a celebrated figure in Wrexham’s history. His first stint at the club began in 1992 after transferring from Chester City. Bennett played a pivotal role in the promotion-winning campaign of 1992/1993, earning the nickname “Psycho” for his tenacious playing style.

8. Carlos Edwards

A national hero in Trinidad and Tobago, Carlos Edwards made a significant impact during his tenure at Wrexham. Known for his versatility as both a full-back and a winger, Edwards was instrumental in the 2002/2003 season, scoring ten goals and earning the club’s Player of the Year award, as well as a place on the PFA Team of the Year.

7. Paul Mullin

Currently on loan at Wigan Athletic, Paul Mullin stands as a modern legend for Wrexham. After finishing as the top scorer in EFL League Two with Cambridge United in 2021, he joined Wrexham and quickly made his mark. Mullin scored 38 league goals, helping the club earn promotion to League Two as champions and continued his scoring prowess the following year.

6. Darren Ferguson

The son of renowned manager Sir Alex Ferguson, Darren Ferguson carved out his own legacy at Wrexham as a player. After joining from Wolves in 1999, he made over 300 appearances, often serving as captain. Ferguson’s leadership was crucial in the club’s 2005 Football League Trophy victory and in securing four FAW Premier Cup titles.

5. Mickey Thomas

An iconic winger, Mickey Thomas played a significant role during Wrexham’s golden era in the mid-to-late 20th century. His contributions included aiding the club’s promotion in 1978 and delivering one of the most memorable moments in FA Cup history with a stunning free-kick against Arsenal in 1992, a match that remains legendary among fans.

4. Bert Goode

Although few modern fans witnessed Bert Goode in action, his contributions to Wrexham’s early history are undeniable. Active in the 1910s and 1920s, Goode was a prolific forward and top scorer in several seasons. His performance in the FA Cup was particularly noteworthy, highlighting his ability to deliver in crucial moments.

3. Arfon Griffiths

Known affectionately as ‘Mr Wrexham,’ Arfon Griffiths is a celebrated figure in the club’s history. Over a career spanning two decades, he made over 500 league appearances and scored 120 goals. Griffiths played a vital role in the club’s promotion to the Second Division in 1978 and earned international caps for Wales, a rarity for Wrexham players at the time.

2. Gareth Davies

Spanning a career from 1967 to 1983, Gareth Davies became a club legend, even earning a testimonial attended by George Best. The centre-back was instrumental during the club’s glory years in the 1970s, winning multiple Welsh Cups and leading the team to the quarter-finals of the 1975/1976 European Cup Winners’ Cup.

1. Tommy Bamford

Ranked as Wrexham’s greatest player, Tommy Bamford remains the club’s all-time top goal-scorer. Signed in 1928, he netted an incredible 175 league goals in just 204 appearances, including a record-setting 44 goals in the 1933/1934 season. Bamford’s legacy endures, with a suite named in his honor at the Racecourse Ground.

As Wrexham continues its journey in the Championship, the contributions of these players remain a testament to the club’s rich history and enduring legacy. Their achievements not only shaped the club’s past but also inspire future generations as Wrexham aims for greater heights in English football.