Supermarket Mini Eggs Taste Test Reveals Surprising Winners

The rising cost of Cadbury’s Mini Eggs, now priced at a staggering £2.00 for a 74g bag, has prompted shoppers to seek alternatives. With each egg costing nearly 9 pence, many consumers are questioning their affordability, especially during the Easter season. In response, food critic Laura Stott conducted a taste test of various supermarket mini egg alternatives, evaluating both flavor and value for money.

Cadbury Mini Eggs: A Nostalgic Standard

Starting with the classic, the Cadbury Mini Eggs, packaged in a 74g bag containing 23 eggs, boast a familiar sugar-coated shell and the nostalgic taste of Dairy Milk chocolate. Despite their beloved status, Stott rated them 2 out of 5, noting that while they offer a pleasant experience, the flavor did not quite match her memories. The higher price point makes them a less attractive option for families looking to stock up for Easter activities.

Exploring Supermarket Alternatives

Stott evaluated several supermarket brands, revealing a mixed bag of options that vary in taste and cost. The M&S Milk Chocolate Choccy Eggs, priced at £2.75 for 130g (containing 27 eggs), stood out for their rich flavor. Though they are on the pricier side at 10 pence per egg, their creamy texture and hint of vanilla earned them a 3 out of 5 rating.

Sainsbury’s Milk Chocolate Mini Eggs, available for £1.15 for 75g (with 15 eggs), provided a more economical choice, costing 7 pence each. Stott found them visually appealing but noted the limited quantity in the bag made them less favorable for large gatherings, ultimately rating them 3 out of 5.

Lidl’s Mister Choc Chocolate Eggs, priced at £1.15 for 80g (containing 22 eggs), offered a sweet and crunchy experience. At 5 pence each, they proved to be a good value option, resulting in a strong 4 out of 5 rating.

Aldi’s Choceur Chocolate Eggs emerged as a budget-friendly champion at 99 pence for 74g (with 20 eggs). Priced at 4.9 pence per egg, they delivered a satisfying flavor profile that Stott described as comparable to the more expensive brands, earning them a commendable 4 out of 5.

The Co-op’s Chocolate Chick Eggs, available at a member price of £1.00 for 80g (containing 21 eggs), stood out for their taste and size. Stott preferred their flavor over Cadbury’s, rating them 4 out of 5.

Morrisons’ Crackin’ Up Chocolate Eggs, priced at £1.25 for 80g (with 21 eggs), were less visually appealing but still delivered a delightful chocolate experience, resulting in a 3 out of 5 score.

Finally, Stott reviewed Asda’s Milk Chocolate Mini Eggs, which are priced at £1.12 for 80g (containing 22 eggs). At 5 pence each, they were noted for their fresh taste and larger size, ultimately receiving a top score of 5 out of 5.

Conclusion: Worth the Hunt?

As Easter approaches, shoppers now have a variety of options beyond Cadbury’s iconic Mini Eggs. With several supermarket alternatives offering competitive prices and satisfying flavors, families can enjoy the festive season without breaking the bank. Stott’s taste test demonstrates that there are delightful, budget-friendly choices available, proving that quality and value can go hand in hand during the holiday season.